The moment a founder tells me the price, I ask what proportion is payable at completion.

There is often a pause. Then a figure that is meaningfully lower than the one they led with, followed by an explanation of how the rest is achievable, and how the buyer has been reasonable about the targets, and how the business is well positioned to hit them.

Sometimes it is. Industry data on earn-outs consistently shows that a substantial proportion pay out below target, and the founders I have watched go through them describe the experience in terms that have nothing to do with the money.

None of which makes earn-outs wrong. They exist for a legitimate reason and sometimes they are the right structure. What is wrong is treating the headline figure as the price, and then negotiating the protections as an afterthought.

A note before anything else: this is a description of how these structures behave commercially, drawn from experience on both sides of the table. It is not legal, tax or financial advice, and every deal turns on its own drafting. Take proper advice on yours.

01Why do buyers want an earn-out?

Because they are being asked to pay today for performance that has not happened yet, and they cannot verify the thing that most affects it, which is how much of the business is you.

From the buyer's side this is entirely reasonable. They have spent eight weeks looking at your company and they still cannot know whether your largest customers stay when you leave, whether your team performs without you, or whether the pipeline is as real as the spreadsheet. An earn-out prices that uncertainty by making you carry it.

Understanding this changes how you negotiate. The earn-out is not an insult and it is not a haggling tactic. It is a measurement of how dependent your business looks. Which means the single most effective way to reduce it is to reduce that dependence in the two years before you sell, not to argue about it in week nine.

02What actually goes wrong?

Four things, in roughly this order of frequency.

You lose control of the denominator. This is the central problem and everything else is a variation of it. Your earn-out is measured on some number, and after completion the buyer controls almost every input to that number. They set pricing, they allocate overhead, they decide which opportunities the group pursues, they may move customers between entities, and they decide what gets invested.

None of that requires bad faith. A buyer making perfectly sensible decisions for the group can reduce your measured performance substantially. If the parent decides to integrate your sales team into theirs, that may be genuinely correct and it may also make your revenue target unreachable.

The metric gets gamed by accident. Profit-based earn-outs are the most exposed, because profit is the output of dozens of accounting choices. Management charges from the parent. Cost allocations. Changes to accounting policy on revenue recognition. Capitalisation decisions. Each is defensible in isolation and together they can move the number a long way.

Revenue-based earn-outs are harder to manipulate and are correspondingly resisted, because they let a seller chase revenue at any margin. A common resolution is revenue with a margin floor, which is more complex and usually fairer to both.

The period is too long. Three years is common and is a long time to remain in a business you no longer own, under somebody else's direction, with your remaining consideration dependent on their decisions. Two years is better. One is better still.

You stop being a founder and become an employee with a bonus scheme. This is the part nobody warns founders about and it is the part they talk about afterwards. The autonomy is gone, the decisions you would have made are made by somebody else, and you are held to a target you no longer control. Some founders manage it well. Many find that the eighteen months after completion are the least enjoyable of their working life.

An earn-out asks you to guarantee a future you will not be in charge of. Price it accordingly, or negotiate the control you would need to deliver it.

03What protections are worth negotiating?

All of these are negotiated before signing or not at all. Once the deal completes, your leverage is gone.

Conduct of business covenants. Undertakings from the buyer about how the business will be run during the earn-out period: that it will be operated as a separate unit, that resources will not be reduced below an agreed level, that customers will not be moved, that pricing will not be changed without consent. This is the single most important protection and the one most often left thin.

Accounting policy fixed at completion. The earn-out accounts are prepared on the same basis as the historic accounts, with the policies specified in the agreement rather than left to the buyer's group standard.

A cap on management charges and a defined basis for cost allocation, so the parent cannot recharge its way through your profit.

Acceleration on specific events. If the buyer sells the business, restructures it, terminates your employment other than for cause, or breaches the conduct covenants, the earn-out becomes payable in full or on an agreed formula. Without this, an acquirer who no longer wants you can simply remove you and the remaining consideration disappears.

Information rights. Monthly management information for the business as measured, so you can see the number moving rather than learning the outcome at the end of the period.

A defined dispute mechanism. An independent expert, with a timetable, rather than litigation. Earn-out disputes are common and expensive, and the mechanism decides how bad that gets.

Your role, in writing. What authority you have, who you report to, what you can decide alone. If you are being held to a number, you need the authority to affect it, and this should be in the agreement rather than the offer letter.

04When should you trade the earn-out away?

More often than founders do.

Run the arithmetic properly. If the deal is £8m with £5m at completion and £3m over three years, ask what certain number today you would accept instead. Discount the earn-out for the probability of achieving it, the time value of money, and the cost of three years of your life spent working for somebody else. Many founders, doing this honestly, find that £6m certain is worth more to them than £8m structured, and would have taken it had they framed the question that way.

Do this before the process reaches term sheet, because by then you are emotionally committed to the headline number and will find reasons to believe in it.

There are also situations where the earn-out is genuinely good for you. If you believe strongly in the growth, if you want to stay anyway, if the buyer brings distribution that will make your targets easy, then the structure can pay considerably more than a clean sale. Those situations exist. They are less common than the number of earn-outs signed would suggest.

05The thing to take away

Negotiate the earn-out with the same seriousness as the price, because it is the price. The protections are worth more than an extra half turn on the multiple, and they cost nothing to ask for.

And be honest with yourself about the eighteen months afterwards. The money is only part of what you are agreeing to. The rest is who you will be reporting to, on Monday mornings, in a business that used to be yours.